- How is sludge different from doom?
- Temperament and tone. Doom is stately and tragic with comparatively clean tone and a funeral pace. Sludge is filthy and volatile, borrows punk's aggression, drives the fuzz into collapse, shouts rather than sings, and drops hardcore sprints into the middle of a slow passage. Doom mourns; sludge seethes.
- My results keep coming out as generic slow metal.
- Name three things: high-gain fuzz with feedback left in, torn shouted vocals, and slow sections alternating with hardcore acceleration. Asking for slow and heavy alone returns a clean doom tone with none of the grime.
- How do I stop it sounding over-produced?
- Ask for lo-fi capture, distorted bass doubling the guitar, dirty cymbals and a live-room feel, and explicitly rule out polished separation. Sludge depends on frequencies crowding each other; a tidy mix removes the whole point.