- How does modal improvising differ from ordinary jazz improvising?
- Ordinary jazz soloing follows chords that turn over every couple of bars and rewards navigation. Modal soloing holds one scale for eight to sixteen bars, so variety has to come from register, density, timbre and rhythmic grouping. Prompting “one mode held for sixteen bars, avoid cadences” works far better than asking for jazz improvisation.
- How do I stop the system putting chord changes back in?
- Prohibit them item by item: “bass stays on a pedal, no walking line,” “piano uses quartal voicings only, no dominant resolutions,” “stay in Dorian throughout, no modulation.” Models default to completing functional harmony, so each escape route has to be closed.
- Where is the line between modal jazz and ambient?
- Modal jazz keeps an explicit drum groove and live improvised playing; only the harmony is frozen. Ambient removes the pulse and works through sustained texture. Ask for modal when you want rhythm with motionless harmony, ambient when you want a beatless field.